The founder of a popular DeFi protocol is promising to make users whole after a scandal-ridden price implosion, but the path to achieving that isn’t totally clear.
On Monday, embattled developer Daniele Sestagalli took to Discord to answer questions from the Wonderland protocol community – a rancorous 45 minutes featuring big promises and bluster, but few specifics on how the project will move forward on leveraging its $325 million treasury to deliver value for tokenholders.
Wonderland, as well as a number of associated decentralized finance protocols loosely united under the “Frog Nation” banner led by Sestagalli, was rocked last week by the revelation from on-chain analyst zachXBT that pseudonymous Wonderland treasurer “Sifu” was in fact Michael Patryn, the co-founder of the fraudulent cryptocurrency exchange QuadrigaCX.
Read more: How Did a Former Quadriga Exec End Up Running a DeFi Protocol? Wonderland Founder Explains
While Patryn has since reportedly been relieved of his duties following a DAO vote on his ouster at a 90-to-10 margin – and, as of Tuesday morning, has moved $2.8 million worth of ETH from his publicly-known address to privacy mixer Tornado Cash – the question remains of what to do with Wonderland’s treasury.
Wonderland’s TIME token currently has a market capitalization of $320 million, just below the $325 million in its coffers.
While some holders are advocating to dissolve the project by allowing tokenholders to redeem their TIME for a proportional share of the protocol’s assets, most investors bought at a valuation many multiples above the current treasury, prompting others to push for an outcome that could pump prices once more.
In Discord chats on Monday, Sestagalli – who indicated his desire to see the project dissolved over the weekend – vowed to push forward in an effort to help users.
“What we need to do is to find a PLAN to get the frogs back on their feet,” he wrote in a string of messages emblematic of his erratic, populist communications style.
So far that plan is beginning to take shape in a handful of current and former proposals from across Frog Nation, none of which so far have garnered popular support among the largely disgruntled investor community.
Sestagalli founded Wonderland in September 2021. A fork of Olympus DAO – a notorious sky-high APY rebasing project frequently lambasted as unsustainable – according to an November 2021 interview Sestagalli initially envisioned Wonderland as a perpetual, “mega-ICO,” distributing tokens to holders over time and building a treasury.
At the time Sestagalli was aiming to eventually leverage TIME as an in-game currency for a wide range of games, including a role-playing game (RPG) Sestagalli said was under development in 2021.
Since then, the vision has expanded for the treasury to become a community-owned investment fund, mirroring a strategy from Redacted Cartel and others that use Olympus’ tokennomics to bootstrap deposits for the fund.
Indeed, as Wonderland eventually overtook Olympus in market capitalization and treasury size, Sestagalli and Patryn made seed investment into a number of projects and grew notorious for large, unilateral investments. Sestagalli in particular popularized a narrative where the Frog Nation investors would eventually compete with and replace “the suits” – shorthand for traditional investment funds.
However, the Olympus model has come under fire in recent weeks amid a crippling drawdown in both the original project and its various forks. In the days prior to Sifu’s unmasking as Patryn, Wonderland fell as much as 40% in a 24-hour period, dropping as far as 95% of its highs.
Read more: Wonderland’s TIME Sets Low of $420 After Liquidation Cascade
The already anemic price action took another hit with Patryn’s reveal. In an interview with CoinDesk, Sestagalli revealed he had known Patryn’s identity for a number of weeks but chose to continue working with him anyway, a dynamic which has led to a crisis in confidence from investors.
Despite the project’s founder actively choosing to work with a convicted felon, on Monday a vote to end Wonderland’s operations and disburse the treasury to investors failed to pass – a sign that either token holders still have faith is Sestagalli’s ability to turn things around, or that they’re reluctant to book their losses.
The failed vote was controversial from the outset.
Depending on the particular DAO, the outcomes of votes may programmatically and automatically prompt actions on-chain, altering the code for a protocol or leading to treasury disbursements, among other functionalities.
In Wonderland’s case, however, the protocol’s rarely-invoked DAO has hosted a total of just eight votes, and the outcome of votes are merely signals of the community’s desires – desires that the Wonderland team can then hypothetically choose whether or not to enact.
This dynamic led to tensions over the weekend, as a tweet from Sestagalli seemed to indicate that Wonderland would be shutting down regardless of the outcome of the “Wind down Wonderland” vote:
The duty of the Team is to enact the will of the token holders. As the vote is so close to 50/50 there is only one path forward, it is to reimburse / unwind who does not feel be part of Wonderland and find a new home for who feels attached & inline with the Frog Nation Vision.
— Daniele never asks to DM (@danielesesta) January 30, 2022
On Monday, however, the vote concluded with 55% of the token weight in favor of the project carrying on. With over 22,000 addresses voting, it was perhaps the post active governance proposal in history, with the vast majority of individual addresses voting to continue the project, outpacing a much smaller number of “whales” who controlled large sums of tokens voting to cease operations.
Sestagalli in turn backtracked on unilaterally closing shop, writing in Discord that the team was taking time to “compile suggestions, and determine the best path forward.”
“We understand that there is still will to continue, the community wants to make it. Unwinding for many of you means taking a loss and you don’t know what to do next. You believed in me and you want to keep [invested] in me,” he wrote.
He added that the protocol was looking to hire a communications team, and that the DAO would be “managed now by me Directly” moving forward.
While it might seem absurd to outsiders that the majority of voters would vote to continue, in the Discord multiple users are expressing support for carrying the project on, either supporting “Dani’s vision,” or saying that, due to their losses on TIME, they are in effect trapped.
In the absence of any action from law enforcement or regulatory authorities, the experiment now appears poised to move forward.
In an interview with CoinDesk on Monday, Sestagalli said he was not worried about whether Patryn’s former involvement and the structure of the Wonderland fund could prompt regulatory action.
“It should worry everyone because most DeFi is like this,” he said. “I can worry or find solutions.”
At least in theory what happens next is up to the DAO, and there are a number of options being discussed.
Prior to Patryn’s reveal last week, the team for Abracadabra – an affiliated asset-backed stablecoin protocol – proposed acquiring Wonderland’s treasury.
Similar to the xDAI and Gnosis merger or the Rari Capital and Fei merger, this would include a token swap that would allow users to exchange TIME for Abracadabra’s SPELL, hypothetically allowing TIME holders upside in the joint venture – a key goal in the proposal, Sestagalli told CoinDesk last week.
While Abracadabra is revenue-generating and its MIM stablecoin is among the most popular in DeFi, MIM briefly lost its peg last week amid the uproar, and efforts from the protocol to bribe its way onto the Aave lending platform now may be at risk.
Read more: DeFi Users Fret ‘Contagion’ Risk Amid Possible Stablecoin Depegging
Additionally, a number of proposals have emerged on the Wonderland governance forums to keep the treasury independent while replacing Sifu with another asset manager.
While no one proposal has yet gained traction, Sestagalli says that unlike in the past, he’ll be moving forward carefully.
“I need to slow down and listen to the community,” he said.